JustRedPillMe JustRedPillMe

Facts. Evidence. Data.

We archive evidence and proof of claims or events.

California Budgeted to Repay $668 Million in Federal Medicaid Funds for Immigrant Care That Should Have Been State-Funded


Claim: California Budgeted to Repay $668 Million in Federal Medicaid Funds for Immigrant Care That Should Have Been State-Funded
Rating: True
Finding: In 2020, California budgeted $668.1 million General Fund to repay federal Medicaid it said it had claimed for immigrant care that should have been state-funded.

Redpill Rating: COMPLETE REDPILL(true)

1California budgeted to repay $668 million in federal Medicaid funds for immigrant care that should have been state-funded

Verdict: True.

  • What the enacted budget shows: The California Legislative Analyst’s Office’s October 15, 2020 health spending-plan report lists a 2020-21 Medi-Cal General Fund line of $668.1 million under “Repays the federal government for erroneous claiming.” That is the figure in the title.
LAO 2020-21 health spending plan: Repays the federal government for erroneous claiming, $668.1 million
LAO 2020-21 health spending plan: Repays the federal government for erroneous claiming, $668.1 million
  • What DHCS said in May 2020: The Department of Health Care Services’ May Revision Highlights said California provides state-only full-scope Medi-Cal to eligible, nonexempt, qualified immigrants, and that under those rules federal financial participation is only available for emergency and pregnancy-related services. The May Revision included $1.4 billion General Fund in 2020-21 to return federal funding that is estimated to have been claimed for ineligible covered benefits.
DHCS May 2020 Revision Highlights: State-Only Claiming section saying $1.4 billion General Fund to return federal funding claimed for ineligible covered benefits
DHCS May 2020 Revision Highlights: State-Only Claiming section saying $1.4 billion General Fund to return federal funding claimed for ineligible covered benefits
  • What the May Medi-Cal estimate scored: DHCS Policy Change 244, “State Only Claiming Adjustments,” estimated reimbursement to the federal government for claiming non-emergency or non-pregnancy related services for those state-only qualified immigrants. On the estimate’s fund table that line shows federal funds of ($817,325,000) and General Fund of $519,592,000. A related behavioral-health line (Policy Change 238) scored another ($148,514,000) in federal funds for Specialty Mental Health and Drug Medi-Cal claimed for ineligible beneficiaries back through FY 2008-09.
DHCS May 2020 Medi-Cal Estimate Policy Change 244: State Only Claiming Adjustments with federal funds of ($817,325,000)
DHCS May 2020 Medi-Cal Estimate Policy Change 244: State Only Claiming Adjustments with federal funds of ($817,325,000)
DHCS May 2020 Medi-Cal Estimate narrative for Policy Change 244 describing reimbursement for non-emergency services claimed for qualified immigrants on state-only Medi-Cal
DHCS May 2020 Medi-Cal Estimate narrative for Policy Change 244 describing reimbursement for non-emergency services claimed for qualified immigrants on state-only Medi-Cal
  • How the LAO explained the discovery: The LAO wrote that in early 2020 the administration found the state had been erroneously claiming federal funding for “state-only” populations since 2010. Those are people who do not meet federal immigration-status rules for full Medicaid, so the state is supposed to pay 100 percent of most of their care. The administration’s May cost estimate was about $966 million General Fund in 2020-21 (including Developmental Services). The Legislature then reduced that 2020-21 amount, which is how the spending plan landed at the $668.1 million repayment line.
LAO explanation that in early 2020 California discovered it had been erroneously claiming federal funding for state-only immigrant Medi-Cal populations since 2010
LAO explanation that in early 2020 California discovered it had been erroneously claiming federal funding for state-only immigrant Medi-Cal populations since 2010
  • Who is in that “state-only” bucket: DHCS’s May writeup names qualified immigrants on state-only full-scope Medi-Cal. In federal Medicaid rules, that usually means people such as lawful permanent residents still inside the five-year wait. The LAO’s wording is broader: populations that fail federal immigration eligibility for full Medicaid. California’s later state-funded expansions for people without satisfactory immigration status, including undocumented adults, sit in the same legal bucket for federal match: non-emergency care is supposed to be state money. Emergency and certain pregnancy-related care can still draw federal funds.
  • Why state funds were required: Federal law generally bars full federal public benefits for aliens who are not qualified aliens, and Medicaid matching funds for people without satisfactory immigration status are limited to treatment of an emergency medical condition. States may still cover more with their own money. The 2020 papers are about federal dollars claimed for care outside that emergency/pregnancy window.
8 U.S.C. section 1611: an alien who is not a qualified alien is not eligible for any federal public benefit except as provided in subsection (b)
8 U.S.C. section 1611: an alien who is not a qualified alien is not eligible for any federal public benefit except as provided in subsection (b)
42 U.S.C. section 1396b(v): no federal Medicaid payment for medical assistance to an alien not lawfully admitted, except care necessary to treat an emergency medical condition
42 U.S.C. section 1396b(v): no federal Medicaid payment for medical assistance to an alien not lawfully admitted, except care necessary to treat an emergency medical condition
  • What the $668 million is: It is the 2020-21 General Fund the spending plan put toward repaying the federal government and stopping the bad claiming. It is not a published CMS audit that says “exactly $668 million of federal dollars were claimed for undocumented immigrants only.” The May Revision’s larger $1.4 billion figure was an earlier estimate before the Legislature reduced the 2020-21 cost. We do not have a separate CMS cash-receipt PDF in this package for the final repayment total.

In plain language:

Yes. California’s own 2020 Medi-Cal budget papers said it had been claiming federal Medicaid for immigrant care that should have been state-funded, and the enacted spending plan budgeted $668.1 million General Fund to repay and stop that claiming.

Links to Evidence

Redpill Rating: COMPLETE REDPILL(true)